MINILATERALISM IN THE FRAMEWORK OF MULTILATERALISM: SYNTHESIS OF TRENDS
Keywords:
minilateralism, multilateralism, pluralism, polysubjectivity, platform
Abstract
The article analyzes the tendency of the minilateral agreement format as a more effective mechanism for solving modern geopolitical challenges, compared to the multilateralism traditions. Regional platforms for international economic cooperation such as the EU and ASEAN are gradually being supplanted by “global” mini-plurilateralism, while the vast majority of Indo-Pacific players practice narrowly focused on minilateralism, on par with traditional multilateral institutions. Although mini-party structures cannot completely replace multi-format organizations to achieve “real” global cooperation, they can complement their activities by creating an additional platform for diplomacy within a narrow circle of “willings” who share the same views on the agenda during the allotted period. Synthesizing the structural approach with the case study method, the author searches for optimal ways of combining the preferences of the minilateral format with the multilateral institutions’ procedures through the collaborative platform creation for joint actions. The article specifies the cases of minilateral agreements in the security, infrastructure, and economic spheres in the EU countries and the Indo-Pacific region, and also notes the risks of complete replacement by minilateralism, namely: delegitimization of traditional international actors, fragmentation of political standards and norms, inconsistency of national positions with global obligations, increasing the level of tension and mistrust between the leading geopolitical actors. The author considers the rationalization of investment flows concerning mini-layered projects as one of the optimal ways, firstly, the implementation of joint measures subordinated to a common goal, rather than the multiplication of autonomous agreements and obligations.
References
Alles, D., & Fournol, T. (2023). Multilateralisms and Minilateralisms in the Indo-Pacific. Articulations and Convergences in a Context of Saturation of Cooperative Arrangements. INALCO, 8, 24 [in English]. [Alles D., Fournol T. Multilateralisms and Minilateralisms in the Indo-Pacific. Articulations and Convergences in a Context of Saturation of Cooperative Arrangements. INALCO. 2023. Vol. 8, 24, 24 р.].
Council of the EU (2016). Council Conclusions on Implementing the EU Global Strategy in the Area of Security and Defence, Press Release, Brussels, European Union [in English]. [Council of the EU. Council Conclusions on Implementing the EU Global Strategy in the Area of Security and Defence. Press Release. Brussels, European Union. 2016. URL: https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/pressreleases/2016/11/14/conclusions-eu-global-strategy-security-defence/ (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Council of the EU (2019). Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO)’s Projects: Overview (Brussels, European Union) [in English]. [Council of the EU. Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO)’s Projects: Overview (Brussels, European Union). 2019. URL: https://www.consilium.europa.eu/media/41330/pescoprojects-12-nov-2019-rev.pdf. (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
EDA. (2019). Defence Data 2016–2017, Brussels. European Defence Agency, 35 [in English]. [EDA. Defence Data 2016–2017. Brussels, European Defence Agency. 2019. Vol. 35. 16 p.].
EEAS (2017). EU Battlegroups. A Factsheet, Brussels, European External Action Service, 23 [in English]. [EEAS. EU Battlegroups. A Factsheet, Brussels, European External Action Service. October 9, 2017 URL: https://www.eeas.europa.eu/node/33557_en (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)]
EEAS (2018). Permanent Structured Cooperation – PESCO, Brussels, European External Action Service, 32 [in English]. [EEAS. Permanent Structured Cooperation – PESCO, Brussels, European External Action Service, 32. 2018. URL: https://www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/permanent-structured-cooperation-pesco_en (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Frymark, K. (2018). Germany and the V4: Renewed Cooperation Opportunities in the New Political Context, Policy Brief Think Visegrád, Prague, Europeum [in English]. [Frymark, K. Germany and the V4: Renewed Cooperation Opportunities in the New Political Context, Policy Brief Think Visegrád, Prague, Europeum. December 28, 2018. URL: https://europeum.org/en/articles/detail/2472/germany-and-the-v4-renewedcooperation-opportunities-in-the-new-political-context (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Gauck, J. (2014). Germany’s Role in the World: Reflections on Responsibility, Norms and Alliances, speech by Federal President Joachim Gauck at the Opening of the Munich Security Conference, Munich [in English]. [Gauck J. Germany’s Role in the World: Reflections on Responsibility, Norms and Alliances, speech by Federal President Joachim Gauck at the Opening of the Munich Security Conference, Munich. 2014. 8 p.].
Haass, R. (2010). The Case for Messy Multilateralism, Financial Times [in English]. [Haass R. The Case for Messy Multilateralism, Financial Times. 2010. URL: https://www.ft.com/content/18d8f8b6-fa2f-11debeed-00144feab49a. (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Helwig, N. (2020). Germany in European Diplomacy: Minilateralism as a Tool for Leadership, German Politics, 29 (1), 1–17 [in English]. [Helwig N. Germany in European Diplomacy: Minilateralism as a Tool for Leadership, German Politics, 2020. Vol. 29, Is. 1. P. 1–17.]
Jaishankar, S. (2020). The India Way. Strategies for an Uncertain World, N-Y.: HarperCollins [in English]. [Jaishankar S. The India Way. Strategies for an Uncertain World, NY. : HarperCollins, 2020, 240 p.]
Jenkins, D., Paoli, G.P., Black, J., Kokkoris, A., & Kepe, M. (2016). Central and Eastern European Countries: Measures to Enhance Balanced Defence Industry in Europe and to Address Barriers to Defence Cooperation Across Europe, Cambridge, RAND Europe [in English]. [Jenkins D., Paoli G. P., Black J., Kokkoris A., Kepe M. Central and Eastern European Countries: Measures to Enhance Balanced Defence Industry in Europe and to Address Barriers to Defence Cooperation Across Europe, Cambridge. RAND Europe. European Defence Agency. 2016. 184 p. URL: https://eda.europa.eu/docs/default-source/documents/rr-1459-eda-central-andeastern-europe-report---technical-annex---final.pdf (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Indonesian Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2021). Statement on Australia’s Nuclear-powered Submarines Program, Communiqué [in English]. [Indonesian Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2021). Statement on Australia’s Nuclear-powered Submarines Program, Communiqué. September 17, 2021. URL: https://kemlu.go.id/portal/en/read/2937/siaran_pers/statement-on-australias-nuclear-powered-submarinesprogram (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Immigration of Cook Islands (April 3, 2023). Prime Minister Mark Brown Meets with U.S. Counterparts in Washington D.C., Communiqué [in English]. [Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Immigration of Cook Islands. Prime Minister Mark Brown Meets with U.S. Counterparts in Washington D.C., Communiqué. April 3, 2023. URL: https://mfai.gov.ck/news-updates/prime-ministermark-brown-meets-us-counterparts-washington-dc (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Mort, E. (2016). Effective Minilateralism for the EU. What, When and How. European Union Institute for Security Studies (EUISS), Brief 17, Paris [in English]. [Mort E. Effective Minilateralism for the EU. What, When and How. European Union Institute for Security Studies, EUISS. June 03, 2016. Brief 17. Paris. 4 p. URL: https://www.iss.europa.eu/content/effective-minilateralism-eu-%E2%80%93-what-whenand-how (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)]
Naim, M. (2009). Minilateralism. The Magic Number to Get Real International Action, Foreign Policy [in English]. [Naim M. Minilateralism. The Magic Number to Get Real International Action, Foreign Policy. 2009. URL: https://foreignpolicy.com/2009/06/21/minilateralism/ (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Patrick, S. (2015). The New “New Multilateralism”: Minilateral Cooperation, but at What Cost? Global Summitry, 1 (2), 115–131 [in English]. [Patrick S. The New “New Multilateralism”: Minilateral Cooperation, but at What Cost? Global Summitry. 2015. Vol. 1, Is. 2. P. 115–131.]
Tan, S.S. (2020). ASEAN Defence Ministers’ Meeting. Minilateralism in the Indo-Pacific. In Minilateralism in the Indo-Pacific The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, Lancang-Mekong Cooperation Mechanism, and ASEAN. Eds. by Bhubhindar Singh and Sarah Teo. London: Routledge [in English]. [Tan S. ASEAN Defence Ministers’ Meeting. Minilateralism in the Indo-Pacific. 1st Edition, 2020 / Minilateralism in the Indo-Pacific The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, Lancang-Mekong Cooperation Mechanism, and ASEAN. Ed. by Bhubhindar Singh and Sarah Teo. London: Routledge. 26 May 2020. 156 p.]
Tirkey, A. (2021). Minilateralism: Weighning the Prospects for Cooperation and Governance. Observer Research Foundation, 489, 25 [in English]. [Tirkey A. Minilateralism: Weighning the Prospects for Cooperation and Governance. Observer Research Foundation. 2021. Issue Brief. No 489. 25 p.]
Visegrád Group (2020a). The Long Term Vision of the Visegrád Group Countries on Their Defence Cooperation [in English]. [Visegrád Group. The Long Term Vision of the Visegrád Group Countries on Their Defence Cooperation. 2020a. URL: http://www.visegradgroup.eu/documents/official-statements. (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Urbanovská, J., Chovančík, M., & Brajerčíková, S. (2022). Minilateral Cooperation in the EU’s Post-Brexit Common Security and Defence Policy: Germany and the Visegrád Countries, Europe-Asia Studies, 74 (3), 402–425 [in English]. [Urbanovská J., Chovančík M., Brajerčíková, S. Minilateral Cooperation in the EU’s Post-Brexit Common Security and Defence Policy: Germany and the Visegrád Countries, Europe-Asia Studies. 2022. Vol. 74, Is. 3. P. 402–425.]
Council of the EU (2016). Council Conclusions on Implementing the EU Global Strategy in the Area of Security and Defence, Press Release, Brussels, European Union [in English]. [Council of the EU. Council Conclusions on Implementing the EU Global Strategy in the Area of Security and Defence. Press Release. Brussels, European Union. 2016. URL: https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/pressreleases/2016/11/14/conclusions-eu-global-strategy-security-defence/ (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Council of the EU (2019). Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO)’s Projects: Overview (Brussels, European Union) [in English]. [Council of the EU. Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO)’s Projects: Overview (Brussels, European Union). 2019. URL: https://www.consilium.europa.eu/media/41330/pescoprojects-12-nov-2019-rev.pdf. (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
EDA. (2019). Defence Data 2016–2017, Brussels. European Defence Agency, 35 [in English]. [EDA. Defence Data 2016–2017. Brussels, European Defence Agency. 2019. Vol. 35. 16 p.].
EEAS (2017). EU Battlegroups. A Factsheet, Brussels, European External Action Service, 23 [in English]. [EEAS. EU Battlegroups. A Factsheet, Brussels, European External Action Service. October 9, 2017 URL: https://www.eeas.europa.eu/node/33557_en (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)]
EEAS (2018). Permanent Structured Cooperation – PESCO, Brussels, European External Action Service, 32 [in English]. [EEAS. Permanent Structured Cooperation – PESCO, Brussels, European External Action Service, 32. 2018. URL: https://www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/permanent-structured-cooperation-pesco_en (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Frymark, K. (2018). Germany and the V4: Renewed Cooperation Opportunities in the New Political Context, Policy Brief Think Visegrád, Prague, Europeum [in English]. [Frymark, K. Germany and the V4: Renewed Cooperation Opportunities in the New Political Context, Policy Brief Think Visegrád, Prague, Europeum. December 28, 2018. URL: https://europeum.org/en/articles/detail/2472/germany-and-the-v4-renewedcooperation-opportunities-in-the-new-political-context (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Gauck, J. (2014). Germany’s Role in the World: Reflections on Responsibility, Norms and Alliances, speech by Federal President Joachim Gauck at the Opening of the Munich Security Conference, Munich [in English]. [Gauck J. Germany’s Role in the World: Reflections on Responsibility, Norms and Alliances, speech by Federal President Joachim Gauck at the Opening of the Munich Security Conference, Munich. 2014. 8 p.].
Haass, R. (2010). The Case for Messy Multilateralism, Financial Times [in English]. [Haass R. The Case for Messy Multilateralism, Financial Times. 2010. URL: https://www.ft.com/content/18d8f8b6-fa2f-11debeed-00144feab49a. (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Helwig, N. (2020). Germany in European Diplomacy: Minilateralism as a Tool for Leadership, German Politics, 29 (1), 1–17 [in English]. [Helwig N. Germany in European Diplomacy: Minilateralism as a Tool for Leadership, German Politics, 2020. Vol. 29, Is. 1. P. 1–17.]
Jaishankar, S. (2020). The India Way. Strategies for an Uncertain World, N-Y.: HarperCollins [in English]. [Jaishankar S. The India Way. Strategies for an Uncertain World, NY. : HarperCollins, 2020, 240 p.]
Jenkins, D., Paoli, G.P., Black, J., Kokkoris, A., & Kepe, M. (2016). Central and Eastern European Countries: Measures to Enhance Balanced Defence Industry in Europe and to Address Barriers to Defence Cooperation Across Europe, Cambridge, RAND Europe [in English]. [Jenkins D., Paoli G. P., Black J., Kokkoris A., Kepe M. Central and Eastern European Countries: Measures to Enhance Balanced Defence Industry in Europe and to Address Barriers to Defence Cooperation Across Europe, Cambridge. RAND Europe. European Defence Agency. 2016. 184 p. URL: https://eda.europa.eu/docs/default-source/documents/rr-1459-eda-central-andeastern-europe-report---technical-annex---final.pdf (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Indonesian Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2021). Statement on Australia’s Nuclear-powered Submarines Program, Communiqué [in English]. [Indonesian Ministry of Foreign Affairs (2021). Statement on Australia’s Nuclear-powered Submarines Program, Communiqué. September 17, 2021. URL: https://kemlu.go.id/portal/en/read/2937/siaran_pers/statement-on-australias-nuclear-powered-submarinesprogram (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Immigration of Cook Islands (April 3, 2023). Prime Minister Mark Brown Meets with U.S. Counterparts in Washington D.C., Communiqué [in English]. [Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Immigration of Cook Islands. Prime Minister Mark Brown Meets with U.S. Counterparts in Washington D.C., Communiqué. April 3, 2023. URL: https://mfai.gov.ck/news-updates/prime-ministermark-brown-meets-us-counterparts-washington-dc (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Mort, E. (2016). Effective Minilateralism for the EU. What, When and How. European Union Institute for Security Studies (EUISS), Brief 17, Paris [in English]. [Mort E. Effective Minilateralism for the EU. What, When and How. European Union Institute for Security Studies, EUISS. June 03, 2016. Brief 17. Paris. 4 p. URL: https://www.iss.europa.eu/content/effective-minilateralism-eu-%E2%80%93-what-whenand-how (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)]
Naim, M. (2009). Minilateralism. The Magic Number to Get Real International Action, Foreign Policy [in English]. [Naim M. Minilateralism. The Magic Number to Get Real International Action, Foreign Policy. 2009. URL: https://foreignpolicy.com/2009/06/21/minilateralism/ (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Patrick, S. (2015). The New “New Multilateralism”: Minilateral Cooperation, but at What Cost? Global Summitry, 1 (2), 115–131 [in English]. [Patrick S. The New “New Multilateralism”: Minilateral Cooperation, but at What Cost? Global Summitry. 2015. Vol. 1, Is. 2. P. 115–131.]
Tan, S.S. (2020). ASEAN Defence Ministers’ Meeting. Minilateralism in the Indo-Pacific. In Minilateralism in the Indo-Pacific The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, Lancang-Mekong Cooperation Mechanism, and ASEAN. Eds. by Bhubhindar Singh and Sarah Teo. London: Routledge [in English]. [Tan S. ASEAN Defence Ministers’ Meeting. Minilateralism in the Indo-Pacific. 1st Edition, 2020 / Minilateralism in the Indo-Pacific The Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, Lancang-Mekong Cooperation Mechanism, and ASEAN. Ed. by Bhubhindar Singh and Sarah Teo. London: Routledge. 26 May 2020. 156 p.]
Tirkey, A. (2021). Minilateralism: Weighning the Prospects for Cooperation and Governance. Observer Research Foundation, 489, 25 [in English]. [Tirkey A. Minilateralism: Weighning the Prospects for Cooperation and Governance. Observer Research Foundation. 2021. Issue Brief. No 489. 25 p.]
Visegrád Group (2020a). The Long Term Vision of the Visegrád Group Countries on Their Defence Cooperation [in English]. [Visegrád Group. The Long Term Vision of the Visegrád Group Countries on Their Defence Cooperation. 2020a. URL: http://www.visegradgroup.eu/documents/official-statements. (дата звернення: 29.02.2014)].
Urbanovská, J., Chovančík, M., & Brajerčíková, S. (2022). Minilateral Cooperation in the EU’s Post-Brexit Common Security and Defence Policy: Germany and the Visegrád Countries, Europe-Asia Studies, 74 (3), 402–425 [in English]. [Urbanovská J., Chovančík M., Brajerčíková, S. Minilateral Cooperation in the EU’s Post-Brexit Common Security and Defence Policy: Germany and the Visegrád Countries, Europe-Asia Studies. 2022. Vol. 74, Is. 3. P. 402–425.]
Published
2024-05-14
Section
INTERNATIONAL MEASURING OF TRANSFORMATION PROCESSES
