POLITICAL TRANSFORMATION OF THE POST-COMMUNIST COUNTRIES OF THE WESTERN BALKANS AFTER 2008

Keywords: politics, transformation, post-communist countries, the Western Balkans

Abstract

The countries of the Western Balkans (WB) from a geographical point of view are Albania, Slovenia, Croatia, Serbia, Montenegro, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Macedonia and the partially recognized Republic of Kosovo, but in the scientific literature it is called those Balkan countries that are not members of the EU. The article selects three cases for study – Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina and North Macedonia, which provide an idea of the differences between individual countries, but also of the common features of The Western Balkans Region. The aim of the research is to identify the results of the political transformation of the Western Balkans countries after 2008, the year of the global economic crisis which had large-scale consequences for all aspects of the socio-political life of the states of the region. In Bosnia and Herzegovina, the process of forming a government both at the national level and at the entity level was delayed due to the dominance of populists in the country's political field, the most influential of whom was Milorad Dodik. Dodik does not want to lose the support of Moscow, a significant factor in his electoral successes, not to mention his main sponsor, so he is playing on the geopolitical rivalry of the great powers. In Macedonia, disagreements between parliamentary parties and ethnic groups can at any time again turn into demonstrations and pogroms, as was the case in 2015 and 2016. The political situation that has developed in the country shows that the Ohrid Agreement of 2001 was far from ideal and could not finally resolve the conflict. Moreover, the provision of the Ohrid Agreement, which provided for the training of thousands of Albanian police officers in the north of the country, rather contributed to the emergence of open hostilities, rather than the settlement of the conflict. The parliamentary crisis of 2016, which led to street demonstrations and the change of the prime minister, was also a strong blow to the country. It follows that the established principle of “proportional representation” and the right of “veto” for the minority in ethnic issues did not help stabilize the parliamentary institution. The Islamic factor plays a significant role in the political life of Albania. On the one hand, the country declares its desire to become a full member of NATO, to integrate into the European space; on the other hand, Albania is the first European country to receive full status in the Organization of Islamic Cooperation. Part of the political elite believes that the Islamic factor in Albanian politics can create serious difficulties in cooperation with Euro-Atlantic partners. Thus, all three countries of the Western Balkans have passed only the first stage of the reform process. The tasks of the second stage will be the formation of a strong civil society, a two-party political system, judicial independence, public control over new media.

References

A pro-Russian candidate is leading the elections in Bosnia and Herzegovina (2018). LB.UA [in Ukrainian]. [На виборах у Боснії і Герцеговині лідирує проросійський кандидат. LB.UA. 2018. URL: https://lb.ua/world/2018/10/08/409431_viborah_bosnii_gertsegovine.html (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Bagatskyi, E. (2013). The inevitability of constitutional changes in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Bulletin of Odessa National University, 18:2(18:3), 147–155 [in Ukrainian]. [Багацький Є. Невідворотність конституційних змін в Боснії і Герцеговині. Вісник Одеського національного університету. 2013. Том. 18. Вип. 2 (18). Ч. 3. С. 147–155.]
Bagatskyi, E. (2014). EU in Bosnia: goals and achievements. Actual problems of politics, 53, 133–142 [in Ukrainian]. [Багацький Є. ЄС в Боснії: цілі та досягнення. Актуальні проблеми політики. 2014. Вип. 53. С. 133–142.]
Bassuener, K. (2005). Missed opportunities and unfinished conclusions are Bosnia's legacy. In: Ibnoezer, G., Flury, F. (eds). After Intervention: Managing Public Security in Post-Conflict Societies – From Intervention to Sustainable Local Government, 74–101. Bureau of Security Policy under the Ministry of Defense of Austria; National Defense Academy; Geneva Center for Democratic Control of the Armed Forces. Vienna – Geneva: GKS – Vienna [in Ukrainian]. [Бассуенер K. Упущені можливості і незроблені висновки – спадщина Боснії. Після інтервенції: Управляння суспільною безпекою у пост конфліктних суспільствах – від втручання до стійкого місцевого самоврядування / ред. Г. Ібноезер, Ф. Флурі ; Бюро політики безпеки при Міністерстві оборони Австрії ; Національна академія оборони ; Женевський центр демократичного контролю над збройними силами. Відень – Женева : GKS – Vienna, 2005. C. 74–101.]
Bowers, S.R. (1984). The Islamic factor in Albanian policy. Institute of Muslim Minority Affairs, 5:1, 123–135 [in English]. [Bowers S.R. The Islamic factor in Albanian policy. Institute of Muslim Minority Affairs. 1984. Vol. 5. Issue 1. P. 123–135. URL: https://doi.org/10.1080/02666958408715886 (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Clayer, N. (2003). God in the “Land of the Mercedes”. The Religious Communities in Albania since 1990. In: P. Jordan, K. Kaser, W. Lukan et alii. Albanien, 277–314 [in English]. [Clayer N. God in the “Land of the Mercedes”. The Religious Communities in Albania since 1990. Albanien / P. Jordan, K. Kaser, W. Lukan et alii. Peter Lang : österreichische Osthefte, halshs-00189819, 2003. P. 277–314.]
Final Agreement for the Settlement of the Differences as Described in the United Nations Security Council Resolutions 817(1993) and 845(1993), the Termination of the Interim Accord of 1995, and the Establishment of a Strategic Partnership between the Parties (2018). Ministry of Foreign Affairs [in English]. [Final Agreement for the Settlement of the Differences as Described in the United Nations Security Council Resolutions 817(1993) and 845(1993), the Termination of the Interim Accord of 1995, and the Establishment of a Strategic Partnership between the Parties. Ministry of Foreign Affairs. 2018. URL: https://www.mfa.gr/images/docs/eidikathemata/agreement.pdf. (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Gallup Balkan Monitor: Insights and Perceptions: Voices of the Balkans (2010). Gallup Balkan [in English]. [Gallup Balkan Monitor: Insights and Perceptions: Voices of the Balkans. Gallup Balkan. 2010. URL: https://www.europeansources.info/record/website-gallup-balkan-monitor-insights-and-perceptionsvoices-of-the-balkans/ (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Gumba, N., & Gaidai, D. (2021). Experience of European integration of the Western Balkans and conclusions for Ukraine. New Europe, 12 [in Ukrainian]. [Гумба Н., Гайдай Д. Досвід євроінтеграції Західних Балкан і висновки для України. New Europe. 2021. № 12. URL: https://neweurope.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Western-Balkans_ukr.pdf (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Ishchenko, N. (August 10, 2021). Experience of the Balkans for Ukraine: How the Macedonians got along with the Albanians. Infopost [in Ukrainian]. [Іщенко Н. Досвід Балкан для України: Як македонці порозумілися з албанцями. Infopost. 10 серпня 2021. URL: https://infopost.media/dosvid-balkan-dlyaukrayiny-yak-makedonczi-porozumilysya-z-albanczyamy/ (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Karavaitseva, O.V. (2015). Electoral system of post-conflict Bosnia and Herzegovina. Actual problems of politics, 54, 153–159 [in Ukrainian]. [Каравайцева О.В. Виборча система постконфліктної Боснії і Герцеговини. Актуальні проблеми політики. 2015. Вип. 54. С. 153–159.]
Key findings of the 2012 Progress Report on Albania (October 10, 2012). European Commission [in English]. [Key findings of the 2012 Progress Report on Albania. European Commission. October 10 2012. URL: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/memo_12_763 (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Kravchenko, O. (2024). The EU decided to start accession negotiations with Bosnia and Herzegovina. LB.UA [in Ukrainian]. [Кравченко O. ЄС вирішив почати переговори про вступ з Боснією і Герцеговиною. LB.UA. 2024. URL: https://lb.ua/world/2024/03/22/604618_ies_virishiv_pochati_peregovori_pro.html (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Macedonia’s conservatives fail to form coalition (January 30, 2017). DW. [in English]. [Macedonia’s conservatives fail to form coalition. DW. January 30 2017. URL: https://www.dw.com/en/macedonias-political-crisiscontinues-as-conservatives-fail-to-form-coalition/a-37325772 (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Macedonia police killed in clashes with ‘terrorists’ (May 10, 2015). BBC [in English]. [Macedonia police killed in clashes with ‘terrorists’. BBC. May 10 2015. URL: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-32674121 (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
NATO foreign ministers concluded a two-day meeting in Brussels (December 5, 2018). Official site of NATO [in Ukrainian]. [Міністри закордонних справ НАТО завершили дводенну зустріч у Брюсселі. Офіційний сайт НАТО. December 5 2018. URL: https://www.nato.int/cps/uk/natohq/news_161116.htm?selectedLocale=uk (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Page of M. Dodik in X. X. https://x.com/miloraddodik?mx=2 [Page of M. Dodik in X. X. URL: https://x.com/miloraddodik?mx=2 (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Palamarchuk, M., & Aleksandrov, O. (Eds.) (2021). The current state and prospects for the development and transformation of the North Atlantic Alliance. Kyiv: NISD [in Ukrainian]. [Сучасний стан і перспективи розвитку й трансформації Північноатлантичного альянсу / М. Паламарчук, О. Александров (заг. ред.). Київ : НІСД, 2021. 36 с.]
Pan-Albanianism: How Big a Threat to Balkan Security? (2004). International Crisis Group [in English]. [Pan-Albanianism: How Big a Threat to Balkan Security? International Crisis Group. Defence Academy of the United Kingdom : Conflict Studies Research Centre, 2004. 47 р.]
Parliamentary elections are taking place in Albania after a heated election campaign (April 25, 2021). Radio Svoboda [in Ukrainian]. [В Албанії відбуваються парламентські вибори після гострої передвиборчої кампанії. Radio Svoboda. 25 квітня 2021. URL: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/31222286.html (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Parliamentary and presidential elections were held in North Macedonia: the opposition has a chance of a majority (May 8, 2024). Radio Svoboda [in Ukrainian]. [У Північній Македонії пройшли парламентські та президентські вибори: опозиція має шанси на більшість. Radio Svoboda. 8 травня 2024. URL: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/news-pivnichna-makedoniia-vybory/32938621.html (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Republika Srpska: All NATO accession decisions on hold, any future status to be negotiated with Serbia (October 18, 2017). UK.Vijesti [in Ukrainian]. [Республіка Сербська: призупинено всі рішення щодо вступу до НАТО, будь-який майбутній статус узгоджуватиметься з Сербією. UK.Vijesti. 18 жовтня 2017. URL: https://uk.vijesti.me/amp/60078 (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
The long shadow of January 21: a lingering failure for Albania’s new justice system (January 21, 2025). Albanian Times [in English]. [The long shadow of January 21: a lingering failure for Albania’s new justice system. Albanian Times. January 21, 2025. URL: https://albaniantimes.al/the-long-shadow-of-january-21-a-lingering-failure-for-albanias-new-justice-system/ (дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Three presidents and many parliaments: how heads of state are elected in Bosnia and Herzegovina (October 20, 2022). Intent.Press [in Ukrainian]. [Три президенти та багато парламентів: як обирають керівників держави у Боснії і Герцеговині. Intent.Press. 20 жовтня 2022. URL: https://intent.press/publications/election/2022/tri-prezidenti-ta-bagato-parlamentiv-yak-obirayut-kerivnikiv-derzhavi-u-bosniyi-igercegovini/(дата звернення: 02.02.2025).]
Published
2025-04-22
Section
INTERNATIONAL MEASURING OF TRANSFORMATION PROCESSES