HYBRID THREATS BASED ON ANTISEMITISM AND ANTI-ISRAELI PROPAGANDA IN CURRENT SPANISH-ISRAELI RELATIONS
Abstract
Israel and Spain have faced a range of security challenges in recent years, including terrorism, cyber-attacks, and disinformation campaigns. Though Spain-Israeli relations have been constantly developing, the researchers point out the contrary views towards Israel within Spanish society and politics. There are organizations as well as individuals within Spanish society that spread antisemitism and anti-Israeli propaganda, often based on a distorted and biased view of the Arab-Israeli conflict mixed with misconceptions, stereotypes, and misinformation about Israel and its policies. Moreover, they are not only threatening the Jewish people, but also undermining the values of tolerance, respect, and human dignity of non-Jewish population in Spain, which are either countering such crimes or supporting them directly or indirectly. Therefore, fighting the antisemitism and anti-Israeli propaganda by Spain with the support from Israel, can strengthen the human rights policies in these countries and contribute to the development of a more tolerant international society. Methodology of this study combines the methods of comparative and descriptive analysis, that are used to investigate the dynamics of mutual relations between Israel and Spain in countering hybrid threats, focusing on antisemitism and anti-Israel propaganda within the context of international relations. The comparative method was used to compare different events in Spain-Israeli relations in order to identify the patterns and tendencies in mutual relations. The descriptive method was used to characterize these peculiarities. Research objectives of this study are aimed at analyzing of the hybrid threats based on antisemitism and anti-Israeli propaganda in current Spanish-Israeli relations and suggest the ways of countering these threats and promoting a more constructive and mutually beneficial relationship. The study seeks to identify mutual mistakes in current Spanish- Israeli relations, and offer a complex understanding of the cooperative efforts necessity. Specific features of this study: the human security problems in international relations are researched, focusing on the examination of the complexities of antisemitic and anti- Israel narratives, mistakes and misconceptions of Spain towards Israel. The study has the following scientific novelty: for the first time in Ukrainian science, the hybrid threats based on antisemitism and anti-Israeli propaganda in current Spanish-Israeli relations have been researched. Main Results of the Study: the clear evidence of increasing antisemitism and anti- Israeli propaganda in Spain, the absence of forceful statements and actions from Spanish authorities towards terrorists and their supporters in EU and the Spanish government`s opposition to recognizing the full and legitimate right of Israel to protect the population of the Holy Land from the Arab terrorist organizations, raises serious concerns and negatively affect the mutual relations between countries.
References
Bennett, W.L., & Livingston, S. (2018). The disinformation order: Disruptive communication and the decline of democratic institutions, European Journal of Communication, 33 (2), 122–139. Retrieved from http://surl.li/iotec [in English]. [Bennett W. L., Livingston S. The disinformation order: Disruptive communication and the decline of democratic institutions. European Journal of Communication. 2018, 33 (2). Р. 122–139. URL: http://surl.li/iotec (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Cooper, A. (2023, June 18). UN Secretary-General Guterres: On UN International Day for Countering Hate Speech, Help Curb Antisemitic Hate Speech at the UN. The Media Line Ltd. Retrieved from http://surl.li/iovqo [in English]. [Cooper A. UN Secretary-General Guterres: On UN International Day for Countering Hate Speech, Help Curb Antisemitic Hate Speech at the UN. The Media Line Ltd. 2023, June 18. URL: http://surl.li/iovqo (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Erdan holds mock Passover seder at UN attended by 70 ambassadors. (2023, March 30). Jewish News Syndicate. Retrieved from https://shorturl.at/bhlzQ [in English]. [Erdan holds mock Passover seder at UN attended by 70 ambassadors. Jewish News Syndicate. 2023, March 30. URL: https://shorturl.at/bhlzQ (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Faggionato, G. (2023, November 25). Israel accuses Spain, Belgium leaders of backing ‘terrorism’ after Gaza remarks, Politico. Retrieved from: http://surl.li/pfbbr [in English]. [Faggionato G. Israel accuses Spain, Belgium leaders of backing ‘terrorism’ after Gaza remarks, Politico. 2023, November 25. URL: http://surl.li/pfbbr (дата звернення: 30.11.2023)].
Gillott, H. (2023, October 19). 'Truly terrifying' rise in Jew hate in Spain as thousands attend pro-Palestinian rallies The Jewish Chronicle. Retrieved from http://surl.li/pfbcg [in English]. [Gillott H. 'Truly terrifying' rise in Jew hate in Spain as thousands attend pro-Palestinian rallies The Jewish Chronicle. 2023, October 19. URL: http://surl.li/pfbcg (дата звернення: 30.10.2023)].
Gorvett, J. (2023, May 20) Catalonia Can’t Quit Madrid. Foreign Policy (FP). Retrieved from https://shorturl.at/kxzFW [in English]. [Gorvett J. Catalonia Can’t Quit Madrid. Foreign Policy (FP). 2023, May 20. URL: https://shorturl.at/kxzFW (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Government urges Israel to respect humanitarian law following violence escalation in Gaza (2023, May 10). The Diplomat in Spain. Retrieved from https://shorturl.at/cosGZ [in English]. [Government urges Israel to respect humanitarian law following violence escalation in Gaza. The Diplomat in Spain. 2023, May 10. URL: https://shorturl.at/cosGZ (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Hajdenberg, J. (2023, February 9). Barcelona mayor severs ties with twin city of Tel Aviv, citing Israeli ‘apartheid’. Jewish News. Retrieved from https://shorturl.at/oHTY9 [in English]. [Hajdenberg J. Barcelona mayor severs ties with twin city of Tel Aviv, citing Israeli ‘apartheid’. Jewish News. 2023, February 9. URL: https://shorturl.at/oHTY9 (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Harkov, L. (2023, May 24). Terror-supporting NGO advises Facebook on Israel content moderation. Jerusalem Post. Retrieved from http://surl.li/iouuw [in English]. [Harkov L. Terror-supporting NGO advises Facebook on Israel content moderation. Jerusalem Post. 2023, May 24. URL: http://surl.li/iouuw (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Inner Conviction. (n.d.). https://www.torahinten.org. Retrieved from https://www.torahinten.org/blog/innerconviction [in English]. [Inner Conviction. (n.d.). URL: https://www.torahinten.org/blog/inner-conviction (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Kahana, A. (2023, February 16). “We cannot put a question mark on Israel”. Israel Hayom, Jewish News Syndicate. Retrieved from https://shorturl.at/cuwz3 [in English]. [Kahana A. “We cannot put a question mark on Israel”. Israel Hayom, Jewish News Syndicate. 2023, February 16. URL: https://shorturl.at/cuwz3 (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Klein, Z. (2023a, June 10). Israel's allies meet in Europe to combat labeling regulations. Jerusalem Post. Retrieved from http://surl.li/iovsi [in English]. [Klein Z. Israel's allies meet in Europe to combat labeling regulations. Jerusalem Post. 2023a, June 10. URL: http://surl.li/iovsi (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Klein, Z. (2023b, May 31). One in four Europeans harbor antisemitic attitudes, new ADL survey shows. Jerusalem Post. Retrieved from https://shorturl.at/qrMT2 [in English]. [Klein Z. One in four Europeans harbor antisemitic attitudes, new ADL survey shows. Jerusalem Post. 2023b, May 31. URL: https://shorturl.at/qrMT2 (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Knesset repeals disengagement law for northern Samaria. (2023, March 21). Jewish News Syndicate. Retrieved from https://shorturl.at/xHIR8 [in English]. [Knesset repeals disengagement law for northern Samaria. Jewish News Syndicate. 2023, March 21. URL: https://shorturl.at/xHIR8 (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Lempkowicz, Y. (2023a, April 26). First-ever ranking of EU Parliament members vote on Israel presented in Brussels. European Jewish Press. Retrieved from https://shorturl.at/bopKS [in English]. [Lempkowicz Y. First-ever ranking of EU Parliament members vote on Israel presented in Brussels. European Jewish Press. 2023a, April 26. URL: https://shorturl.at/bopKS (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Lempkowicz, Y. (2023b, February 12). Israel’s ambassador to Spain attacked by pro-Palestinian activists during conference in Madrid University. European Jewish Press. Retrieved from http://surl.li/ioupq [in English]. [Lempkowicz Y. Israel’s ambassador to Spain attacked by pro-Palestinian activists during conference in Madrid University. European Jewish Press. 2023b, February 12. URL: http://surl.li/ioupq (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Lempkowicz, Y. (2023c, June 13). Spanish Socialist politician resigns after calling her rival ‘Nazi Jew’. European Jewish Press. Retrieved from: https://shorturl.at/bpzEH [in English]. [Lempkowicz Y. Spanish Socialist politician resigns after calling her rival ‘Nazi Jew’. European Jewish Press. 2023c, June 13. URL: https://shorturl.at/bpzEH (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Lempkowicz, Y. (2023d, June 6). Spanish Member of the European Parliament receives an award from Hezbollah-affiliated organization in Beirut. European Jewish Press. Retrieved from https://shorturl.at/xEH37 [in English]. [Lempkowicz Y. Spanish Member of the European Parliament receives an award from Hezbollah-affiliated organization in Beirut. European Jewish Press. 2023d, June 6. URL: https://shorturl.at/xEH37 (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Maneliuk, Yu., & Pashchenko, D. (2022). Antisemitism as a political ideology: origins and modernity. Actual problems of politics, іssue 69, 27–34 [in Ukrainian]. [Манелюк Ю. М., Пащенко Д. Г. Антисемітизм як політична ідеологія: витоки і сучасність. Актуальні проблеми політики. 2022. Вип. 69. С. 27–34. https://doi.org/10.32837/app.v0i69.1298 (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Mualem, M. (2023, May 21). Antisemitism skyrockets on Twitter, as Israel's requests go ignored. Al-Monitor. Retrieved from http://surl.li/iouss [in English]. [Mualem M. Antisemitism skyrockets on Twitter, as Israel's requests go ignored. Al-Monitor. 2023, May 21. URL:http://surl.li/iouss (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Palyvoda, V. (2020). Slovakia's approaches to combating hybrid threats: analyst from NISS expert. National Institute for Strategic Studies. Retrieved from https://niss.gov.ua/en/node/3492 [in Ukrainian]. [Паливода В. Підходи Словаччини до боротьби з гібридними загрозами: аналітика від експерта НІСД. Національний інститут стратегічних досліджень, 2020. URL: https://niss.gov.ua/en/node/3492 (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Radchenko, Yu. (2022). New Perspectives on the Study of the Holocaust in Ukraine from the Perspective of Multiculturalism. Ideology and Politics Journal, 2 (21), 85–104 [in Ukrainian]. [Радченко Ю. Нові перспективи дослідження історії Голокосту в Україні з позиції мультикультуралізму. Журнал «Ідеологія и політика», 2020, 2 (21). С. 85–104].
Robin, M. (2023). European anti-propaganda policies. Robert Schumann Foundation, European Issues, 665. Retrieved from http://surl.li/pfbcr [in English]. [Robin M. European anti-propaganda policies. Robert Schumann Foundation, European Issues, 665. 2023. URL: http://surl.li/pfbcr (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Sherman, Sh. (2023, February 21). Israel refuses entry to member of EU parliament for terror ties. Jewish News Syndicate. Retrieved from https://shorturl.at/uJS24 [in English]. [Sherman Sh. Israel refuses entry to member of EU parliament for terror ties. Jewish News Syndicate. 2023, February 21. URL: https://shorturl.at/uJS24 (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].
Spanish minister wants the world to isolate Israel (2023, November 9) MercoPress. Retrieved from http://surl.li/pfbdn [in English]. [Spanish minister wants the world to isolate Israel. MercoPress. 2023, November 9. URL: http://surl.li/pfbdn (дата звернення: 13.11.2023)].
Staff, T., & AFP (2023, October 24). Israel demands UN chief resign after he says Hamas attacks ‘did not occur in vacuum’ The Times of Israel Retrieved from http://surl.li/pfbed [in English]. [Staff T., AFP. Israel demands UN chief resign after he says Hamas attacks ‘did not occur in vacuum’ The Times of Israel 2023, October 24. URL: http://surl.li/pfbed (дата звернення: 30.10.2023)].
Wagenheim, M. (2023, April 25). Protesting UN debate on Yom Hazikaron, Israeli ambassador reads names of fallen Israelis. Jewish News Syndicate. Retrieved from http://surl.li/iovbw [in English]. [Wagenheim M. Protesting UN debate on Yom Hazikaron, Israeli ambassador reads names of fallen Israelis. Jewish News Syndicate. 2023, April 25. URL: http://surl.li/iovbw (дата звернення: 29.06.2023)].